• Latest
  • All
  • How To
Safaricom Okoa Jahazi

Court Decides; Safaricom Did Not Steal the Okoa Jahazi Idea

May 21, 2020
ios 26 apple

iOS 26: New Features To Expect Ahead of June 9 Launch

June 5, 2025
CA ranked by ITU as best in Africa ICT regulations

Kenya’s ICT Regulation Surpasses US, Crowned Africa’s Best by UN

June 5, 2025
Kenya startup funding growth

New Report: Startup Growth at Risk Due to Foreign Funding Dependence

June 5, 2025
Apple Airpods

AirPods Could Soon Answer Calls and Snap Photos Hands Free

June 5, 2025
DHgate Tablet Cases deals
instagram-edits

Instagram Adds Teleprompter to Edits App in Bid to Rival CapCut

June 5, 2025
Sora

Microsoft Brings Sora AI Video Creator to Bing App

June 5, 2025
google-ai-edge-gallery

New Google App Lets You Use AI Offline on Android

June 5, 2025
adobe-photoshop-iphone

Adobe Launches Photoshop Beta App for Android

June 5, 2025
Material 3 Expressive

Gmail and Messages Get a Colorful Makeover

June 5, 2025
Rose Njeri, the creator of Civic Email

Rose Njeri Charged With Cybercrime for Letting Kenyans Email Their MPs

June 3, 2025
Infinix Hot 60 Pro+ Leaked Design

Infinix Hot 60 Pro+ Could Be the World’s Thinnest Curved Display Phone

June 3, 2025
Infinix Note 50 Pro Review

Infinix Note 50 Pro Review: A Budget Phone Shouldn’t Be This Good

Techweez | Tech News, Reviews, Deals, Tips and How To
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Editorial
No Result
View All Result
Techweez | Tech News, Reviews, Deals, Tips and How To
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Editorial
No Result
View All Result
Techweez | Tech News, Reviews, Deals, Tips and How To
No Result
View All Result

Court Decides; Safaricom Did Not Steal the Okoa Jahazi Idea

June Okal by June Okal
May 21, 2020
in Editorial, Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
262
0
Safaricom Okoa Jahazi

Safaricom Okoa Jahazi

This past week Justice Mary Kasango delivered a  Copyright Infringement decision on a case regarding Safaricom’s Okoa Jahazi product.

The case is Christopher N. Omare and Michael Otachi t/a Omare and Partners v Safaricom Limited [2020] available on Kenya Law Reports online.

The Okoa Jahazi case validates my 'Safaricom Stole my Idea' and Ideas cannot be stolen illustration.. literally. The judgment could have been 'heavier' for our dissertations but it's good precedent

Civil Suit 552 of 2009 – Kenya Law: https://t.co/ypEXN6ULYB

— Miss Okal 🇰🇪 🌍 (@JuneOkal) May 14, 2020

This isn’t the first case that’s been brought against Safaricom on the product. The product has also not been free of hitches like when people accrued huge Okoa Jahazi debt and balances which ran into multiple of thousands.

The plaintiff’s case was that they had title to ownership of a mobile telephone programme which would enable a subscriber to the mobile network to obtain emergency airtime credit in Kenya Shillings.  They called this Emergency Credit Service (ECS).  The purpose of ECS was to provide emergency credit  airtime to subscribers who might have been:

  • Travelling and run out of air time;
  • Be in an area where airtime cannot be obtained;
  • Require to make an emergency call at night; and
  • Those who might not wish to buy in available outlets credit for as little as Ksh 50/- of Ksh 100/=

The Okoa Jahazi service allows Safaricom customers to request an advance of mobile airtime in the amount of Ksh 10/-, 20/-,50/-, 100/-, 250/-, 500/-, and 1,000/-. The case dwells on a claim raised by two innovators that Safaricom stole their idea. 

Copyright covers expressions of the mind’s ideas. In Kenya, software is protected under copyright. Ideas under the law are not worth much, unfortunately. Only until an idea is expressed in one form or the other does it become of value. 

The claim of ‘Safaricom Stole My Idea’ has been a  long-standing running theme in tech circles and the startup scene for a long time. It is important for techies and creatives to realize that legally ideas are not enforceable. 

We all have ideas and like Eric Ries says, more likely than not (for Company led tech products especially) there are in house product teams working on new product improvement concepts and building those solutions that come in as proposals. 

For Safaricom for instance, there have been allegations of in-person pitch meetings or the Zindua Cafe proposal portal which has been referred to over and over again as to how ideas are presented to the company. Zindua cafe launched in 2015 was an online ideas submission portal which allowed members of staff, application developers and members of the public to share their ideas for new applications or services with the telco easily and conveniently. When launched, Zindua Cafe required users to disclose whether submissions were protected as patents, trademarks or copyright in addition to providing the registration numbers and copies of any certificates received from WIPO, KIPI and KECOBO. 

In this case, a proposal was forwarded in 2006 to Safaricom, which they failed to respond to and in March 2009 Safaricom launched into the market a product called “Okoa Jahazi” which allowed its subscriber to access emergency airtime. 

The Court decided that Safaricom successfully proved that prior to receiving the proposal, it had in its possession knowledge of the concept by virtue of learning about if from Vodafone operators and that the concept was in use in India, Egypt and Spain by the time the plaintiffs presented their proposal. 

The Court also indicated that the proposal submitted to Safaricom was so general that even if they took it up, they couldn’t be said to have infringed. The proposal simply stated that mobile subscribers could be given emergency airtime, by the mobile services provider which would then give the mobile provider a return.  Apart from these general statements the proposals bore no other details of how that concept could be worked out.

One of the reasons why the expression of ideas especially in tech solutions is so important is that no two people with individual minds will build a product in exactly the same way. Everyone’s execution is different and unique. Also, in building the product, an innovator is allowed to deeply consider issues that may pop up and in solving for those situations, the product becomes specific. 

When it’s all said and done, ideas are great, they’re awesome. If implemented they could be worth a million dollars. However, the value of just a great idea really is nil – until it is worked upon. 

11 years later since the case was filed in 2009, Safaricom won and the innovators have to pay Safaricom’s legal fees.

‘On the whole I find that the plaintiffs failed to produce cogent evidence to support the claim.  The case therefore does fail with costs.’ – Justice Kasango

Tags: Kenya Copyright Board
SendShare147Tweet92
June Okal

June Okal

'I speak legalese, understand the tech and hack the law.' June Okal is a legal professional in Technology, Media and Telecommunications Law Practice and Co - Organizer of Nairobi Legal Hackers. Her focus areas are Innovation, Intellectual Property and Internet Governance.

Related Posts

Kenya Authorities Make Arrests in Illegal Streaming Case

Kenya Authorities Make Arrests in Illegal Streaming Case

April 25, 2023
Copyright Board Issues Warning to Corporates About Meme Reproduction

Copyright Board Issues Warning to Corporates About Meme Reproduction

August 5, 2022
Kenya Copyright Regulator Warns Brands Against Unauthorized Use of Firirida

Kenya Copyright Regulator Warns Brands Against Unauthorized Use of Firirida

February 27, 2021
IP Bill 2020

Intellectual Property Bill 2020 Proposes to Abolish KIPI, KECOBO and Anti-counterfeit Authority

May 4, 2020
Uhuru Kenyatta

Skiza and Viusasa Not Banned as President Kenyatta Announced New Royalties Distribution Scheme

January 14, 2020
CA Kenya

Kenya Copyrights Board and CA Compel Broadcasters to Acquire Content Licenses Before Distribution

November 19, 2019

Latest

ios 26 apple

iOS 26: New Features To Expect Ahead of June 9 Launch

June 5, 2025
CA ranked by ITU as best in Africa ICT regulations

Kenya’s ICT Regulation Surpasses US, Crowned Africa’s Best by UN

June 5, 2025
Kenya startup funding growth

New Report: Startup Growth at Risk Due to Foreign Funding Dependence

June 5, 2025
Apple Airpods

AirPods Could Soon Answer Calls and Snap Photos Hands Free

June 5, 2025
instagram-edits

Instagram Adds Teleprompter to Edits App in Bid to Rival CapCut

June 5, 2025
Sora

Microsoft Brings Sora AI Video Creator to Bing App

June 5, 2025

Best devices

budget smartwatches 2025

Best Budget Smartwatches To Buy in Kenya 2025

February 13, 2025

Best Infinix Smartphones To Buy in Kenya 2024

February 13, 2025

Best Laptops for Battery Life in 2024

August 21, 2024

Best “Battery Warrior” Smartphones To Buy in 2024

August 22, 2024

iOS 26: New Features To Expect Ahead of June 9 Launch

June 5, 2025

Kenya’s ICT Regulation Surpasses US, Crowned Africa’s Best by UN

June 5, 2025

Techweez is a fast growing influential source of technology news, reviews and analysis by leading tech geeks in the industry.

Follow Us

Editorials

Actors and Film Crews Are Worried About Veo 3 Taking Their Jobs

Samsung QLED TVs Now Officially Certified for Real Quantum Dot Technology

Trump’s Tariffs Will Be the End of Affordable Tech

5 Ways to Prep Your Tech for Resale

The Weaponization of PDFs: How Cybercriminals Are Exploiting a Trusted Format

Introducing A Brainbox Quiz: Techweez’s Monthly Trivia Night!

More News

New Google App Lets You Use AI Offline on Android

Adobe Launches Photoshop Beta App for Android

Gmail and Messages Get a Colorful Makeover

Rose Njeri Charged With Cybercrime for Letting Kenyans Email Their MPs

Infinix Hot 60 Pro+ Could Be the World’s Thinnest Curved Display Phone

Infinix Note 50 Pro Review: A Budget Phone Shouldn’t Be This Good

  • Terms Of Use
  • Techweez Brand
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact Us

© 2024 Techweez - Palahala Media Group may earn a commission when you buy through links on our sites.
A Palahala Media Group Brand. All rights reserved.
.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Techweez | Tech News, Reviews, Deals, Tips and How To
Crunchy Cookies 🍪 Ahead!

Hey there! Just a heads-up: we're big fans of cookies - both the digital and edible kind! 🍪 We use our cookies and some from third parties to ensure your browsing experience on our site is smooth sailing and secure.

 

But wait, there's more! We also use cookies to gather stats and insights on how you navigate our site. It's like getting a behind-the-scenes peek at your digital adventures!

 

Don't worry, you're in control. You can adjust your cookie settings anytime to suit your preferences. Feeling curious? Dive into our Privacy Policy for all the juicy details. Happy browsing! 🚀

Functional Always active
Listen, this legal stuff is about as exciting as watching paint dry. But it basically says we only use your stuff for what you asked us to do, and nobody else gets to peek!
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
It's those sneaky cookie crumbs websites leave behind to count visitors, like counting ants at a picnic! Totally harmless, just for fun facts. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
Hey there! Just letting you know we use some fancy gizmos to remember your preferences. This way, we can show you ads that are, well, not completely bananas.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Make cookies
{title} {title} {title}
Techweez | Tech News, Reviews, Deals, Tips and How To
Crunchy Cookies 🍪 Ahead!
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
Listen, this legal stuff is about as exciting as watching paint dry. But it basically says we only use your stuff for what you asked us to do, and nobody else gets to peek!
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
It's those sneaky cookie crumbs websites leave behind to count visitors, like counting ants at a picnic! Totally harmless, just for fun facts. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
Hey there! Just letting you know we use some fancy gizmos to remember your preferences. This way, we can show you ads that are, well, not completely bananas.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Make cookies
{title} {title} {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Editorial
  • Automotive
  • Entertainment

© 2024 Techweez - Palahala Media Group may earn a commission when you buy through links on our sites.
A Palahala Media Group Brand. All rights reserved.
.